RESULTS
Description
of the study population - The mean age of respondents to the
questionnaire was 39.4 years [standard deviation (SD)=16.3, median
age=35.5 years] and more than 95% of respondents were females. The
age of the 240 subjects sampled ranged from 2 to 84 years with a mean
age of 20.6 years (SD=19.3, median age=11.0). Fifty-three percent of
those sampled were female and 47% male. Seventy-one percent of
respondents had some formal education; the majority (51.6%) had some
primary education (completed 1-6 years) and 19.4% had some years of
secondary education (completed 7-12 years).
Prevalence
and intensity of A. lumbricoides and T. trichiura - The overall
prevalence of A. lumbricoides and T. trichiura in these
four communities was 45% (95% CI 39.0-51.9) and 38% (95% CI
31.8-44.4), respectively (Table I). Over a quarter (25.8%) of the 240
stool specimens examined had double infection of both A.
lumbricoides and T. trichiura. Table I shows the
differences in prevalence and intensity of Ascaris and
Trichuris infection by age group and community. Overall,
infections of Ascaris were mostly moderate and light, except
in El Chaguite where there were heavy infections. There were
primarily light infections of T. trichiura, except again in El
Chaguite where moderate infections were observed. There were no heavy
infections of T. trichiura.
El Llano
had the lowest prevalence overall of both A. lumbricoides and
T. trichiura and the least number of T. trichiura
infections across all age groups. Twenty-two percent of the
population surveyed in this community was infected with Ascaris
and 11% were infected with Trichuris. Most infections,
including one case of heavy infection and two cases of moderate
infection with Ascaris, were found in children 2-4 years old
and 5-12 years old. However, there were no infections of Trichuris
in the 2-4 age group.
El
Chaguite was the community with the highest prevalence of Ascaris
and Trichuris; 82% of those surveyed had infections of Ascaris
and 71% had infections of Trichuris. El Chaguite had much
higher rates of infection in all age groups with A. lumbricoides
and T. trichiura. Most infections of T. trichiura
occurred in those 5-12 years old followed by individuals >12 years
old.
The
prevalence of Ascaris in Santa Ines and El Chaguite-Belen was
29% and 52%, respectively. The prevalence of Trichuris in each
of these communities was 30% and 43%, respectively. In Santa Ines,
individuals aged 2-4, had the highest frequency (40%) of moderate
Ascaris infection, while those aged 5-12 and >12 had
substantial frequencies (close to 30%) of both moderate and light
infections. Individuals aged 5-12 years had the highest frequency
(48%) of light infections of T. trichiura. Twenty percent of
those >12 years old had light infections of Trichuris. In
El Chaguite-Belen the highest frequency of infection (moderate and
light) of Ascaris and Trichuris occurred in those aged
5-12, followed by those aged >12. There was only one infection of
Ascaris or Trichuris in children aged 2-4 in this
community (Table I).
Fig. 2
shows the overall intensity of A. lumbricoides infections in
all the communities. Children aged 2-4 had the heaviest infections
while children aged 5 to 12 were most frequently infected with
moderate and light infections compared to other age groups. Overall,
there were more intense infections (heavy and/or moderate) of Ascaris
than Trichuris in all age groups. Fig. 3 shows the overall
intensity of T. trichiura infections in all the communities.
Children aged 5 to 12 more frequently had moderate and light
infections of Trichuris compared to other age groups. There
were more light infections of Trichuris in children aged 5 to
12 than there were light infections of Ascaris in the same age
group. Also, individuals >12 years were more frequently infected
with light infections of Trichuris than they were with light
infections of Ascaris.
Socio-demographic
characteristics of household by infections of A. lumbricoides and T.
trichiura - Univariate analysis was used to examine relationships
between socio-demographic variables reported for the households and
infections of A. lumbricoides and T. trichiura.
Infections of A. lumbricoides by household associated with
infections of T. trichiura and vice versa (p=0.001)
(Tables II, III).
The four
communities differed markedly from each other with respect to the
prevalence of infections by both parasites, but only A.
lumbricoides infection was significantly associated with
infection by location of the household (p=0.03) (Table II). A higher
percentage of households located in El Chaguite or El Chaguite-Belen,
had members infected with A. lumbricoides than households in
El Llano or Santa Ines. There were significant differences in
prevalence between communities. When El Chaguite was compared
univariately with the other three communities, in every instance,
living in El Chaguite was significantly associated (p<0.01) with
infections of A. lumbricoides or T. trichiura.
There
was an association between the number of children 2 to 5 years old
and the number of children 6-14 years old living in a household, and
infection by A. lumbricoides in members of the household
(p=0.001, p=0.001, respectively) (Table II). Households with children
in these age groups had a greater frequency of Ascaris infection
compared to households with no children in these age groups (Table
II). Similarly, the number of children 6-14 years old in the
household was also associated with infections of T. trichiura
(p=0.01) (Table III). Households with children in this age group had
a greater frequency of Trichuris infections than those
households with no children in the age group.
Education
was associated with A. lumbricoides infection within
households (p=0.01) (Table II). A lower proportion (25%) of family
members was infected with A. lumbricoides in households where
the respondent had a secondary education than in households where the
respondent had no formal education (66.7%).
Gender
was examined as a possible variable associated with parasitoses.
Approximately 45% of males and 45% of females of all ages surveyed
were infected with A. lumbricoides. Approximately 41% of males
and 35% of females of all ages were positive for infections with T.
trichiura. There was no significant difference with respect to
gender regarding infection with either Ascaris (p=0.97) or
Trichuris (p=0.35) in the population surveyed. Also, there was
no significant difference between gender with reference to intensity
for Ascaris (p=0.64) or Trichuris (p=0.20) infections.
Associations
between sanitary practices and infections of Ascaris or
Trichuris by household was also examined. In this respect,
certain variables such as lack of a latrine (p=0.04, p=0.03) (Tables
II, III), respondents defecating in a site other than the latrine
(p=0.01, p=0.04) (Tables II, III), children defecating in a site
other than the latrine (p=0.02) (Table II), and children with a
recent history of diarrrhea (p=0.002) (Table II) were associated with
infections of either A. lumbricoides or T. trichiura
respectively. In each case, households that did not own a latrine, or
households where respondents and children did not always use the
latrine for defecation, or where children were reported with
diarrhea, had a higher percentage of members with infections of
either helminth.
The most
common reason given by respondents who did not always use the latrine
for defecation, was that the family did not own one (31.6%). Other
common reasons given were that the latrine was broken (26.3%) or that
it was too far (21.1%). Twenty-one percent of respondents had reasons
other than those given above. The most common reasons given by
respondents for children not always using the latrine was that the
children did not know how to use it because they were too young
(30%), that the latrine was too far (20%), and that the household did
not own one (20%). Another 16.7% said that the latrine was broken,
and 13.3% indicated other reasons.
Although
most individuals (73.7%) did not know how someone could become
infected with Ascaris, when specifically asked and shown the
preserved specimen of Ascaris, 34.4% recalled that someone in
the household had passed a worm at some time. The answers respondents
gave to the question of how children became infected with worms in
general varied, but most (40.3%) thought that "dirty hands or
filth" was the cause. However, over a third of respondents
(33.9%) did not know how children acquired worms. The remainder
(25.9%) thought that water, candy, milk, eating bad food, etc. caused
worms in children.
Multivariate
analysis of variables associated with infections of A. lumbricoides
and T. trichiura - Multivariate analysis was performed on all the
variables with p-value of 0.05 or less by univariate analysis for
both A. lumbricoides and T. trichiura, in order to
eliminate confounding variables. Multivariate analysis identified the
following variables as those statistically associated with infections
of A. lumbricoides: number of children aged 2-5 or 6-14 living
in the household (p=0.01 and p=0.04, respectively), report of recent
history of diarrhea in children in the household (p=0.01) and members
of the household coinfected with T. trichiura (p=0.02). The
only variable that was associated with T. trichiura infection
was the number of children 6 to 14 years old living in the household
(p=0.01) (Table IV).