Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro, VOLUME 114 | SEPTEMBER 2019
Human virome in nasopharynx and tracheal secretion samples
1Universidade de Brasília, Departamento de Biologia Celular, Pós-Graduação em Biologia Microbiana, Brasília, DF, Brasil
2Universidade Federal Rural de Pernambuco, Departamento de Agronomia, Recife, PE, Brasil
3Laboratório Central de Saúde Pública do Distrito Federal, Brasília, DF, Brasil
4Universidade de Brasília, Departamento de Biologia Celular, Pós-Graduação em Biologia Molecular, Brasília, DF, Brasil
BACKGROUND In Brazil the implementation of the Sentinel Surveillance System of Influenza began in 2000. Central public health laboratories use reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) for diagnosis of respiratory viruses, but this protocol identifies only specific targets, resulted in inconclusive diagnosis for many samples. Thus, high-throughput sequencing (HTS) would be complementary method in the identification of pathogens in inconclusive samples for RT-qPCR or other specific detection protocols.
OBJECTIVES This study aimed to detect unidentified viruses using HTS approach in negative samples of nasopharynx/tracheal secretions by the standard RT-qPCR collected in the Federal District, Brazil.
METHODS Nucleic acids were extracted from samples collected in winter period of 2016 and subjected to HTS. The results were confirmed by the multiplex PR21 RT-qPCR, which identifies 21 respiratory pathogens.
FINDINGS The main viruses identified by HTS were of families Herpesviridae, Coronaviridae, Parvoviridae and Picornaviridae, with the emphasis on rhinoviruses. The presence of respiratory viruses in the samples was confirmed by the PR21 multiplex RT-qPCR. Coronavirus, enterovirus, bocavirus and rhinovirus were found by multiplex RT-qPCR as well as by HTS analyses.
MAIN CONCLUSIONS Wide virus diversity was found by different methodologies and high frequency of rhinovirus occurrence was confirmed in population in winter, showing its relevance for public health.
Worldwide influenza surveillance was initiated in 1947 to monitor circulating viruses and provides information to support the vaccine-type recommendations by the World Health Organization (Geneva, Switzerland) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (Atlanta, USA). Central laboratories (Lacens) in Brazil are responsible for the occurrence reports about the etiologic agents, types and subtypes of circulating respiratory viruses in patients with influenza-like syndrome (ILS) and severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS).(1)
The main technique for detecting respiratory viruses in Lacens is reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR), which advantages are sensitivity, specificity, automation, relatively low cost and so on. However, this technique as well as the conventional RT-PCR are pathogen-specific, which only find pre-defined targets. Thus, a peculiar etiological agent or new genetic variants may not be detected, despite the use of a wide range of sensitive diagnostic tests.(2)
In this context, high-throughput sequencing (HTS) technologies without requiring any prior genomic information provide large volume of nucleotide sequences, resulting in elucidation of unidentified viruses (which were not detectable by the specific detection methods) and furthermore, allow the discovery of new viruses or new genomic variants using metagenomic approaches.
The human population is exposed to increasing burden of infectious diseases caused by the emergence of viruses not yet or rarely characterised. Globalisation, climate change, settlements near wild animal habitats, and increasing numbers of immunocompromised people are likely to contribute to the emergence and spread of new infections.(3) HTS methods have allowed genomic analysis which is sensitive for unknown or peculiar viruses over previous methodologies, such as the analysis of viral genomes used in the identification or discovery of human herpesvirus 8,(4) bocavirus,(5) human parvovirus 4,(6) human GB virus,(7) Torque Teno virus,(8) WU polyomavirus(9) and KI polyomavirus.(10)
HTS has been used, for example, in the discovery of an arenavirus in three patients who died of a febrile illness a few weeks after transplant of solid organs from a single donor.(11) The Illumina platform allowed identifying hepatitis A virus among cases of acute febrile illnesses that occurred in Brazil which were suspected as yellow fever.(12) The same platform was used to identify a new influenza virus from swabs samples and assembly of its genome.(13) It also led to the detection of viral pathogens in nasopharyngeal aspirate samples from patients with acute lower respiratory tract infections, as a new enterovirus, termed enterovirus 109 (EV109) detected in a cohort of Nicaraguan children with viral respiratory disease.(14)
Thereby, this study aimed to detect unidentified viruses by HTS approach in negative samples of nasopharynx/tracheal secretions for diagnostics targeting several viruses collected from June to August 2016 in the Federal District (DF), Brazil.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Detection of standard respiratory viruses - The nasopharyngeal and tracheal secretion samples received in the laboratory in June, July and August 2016 were tested for the respiratory virus diagnostic panel performed in Lacen-DF (Public health laboratory located in the Federal District, Brazil) by the standard RT-qPCR (for Influenza A, Influenza B, Human respiratory syncytial virus, Human metapneumovirus, Human adenovirus C, Parainfluenza 1, Parainfluenza 2 and Parainfluenza 3). Those that had negative results were separated and stored in freezer -70ºC for subsequent DNA/RNA extraction for HTS.
RNA/DNA extraction - Fifty one samples from June, 55 from July and 39 from August of 2016 were mixed, respectively (one for each month), and treated as three pooled samples. Individual sample had a volume of approximately 0.5 mL (total of 20-25 mL of each pooled sample). The volume was adjusted to 50 mL with 0.1 M sodium phosphate buffer (pH7.2) with Triton-X 100 at the final concentration of 1%. The solution in tubes were agitated for 1 h in a cold chamber, then, centrifuged at 4,800 × g for 40 min. The supernatant was ultracentrifuged with 20% sucrose cushion at 140,000 × g for 1 h using Ti45 rotor (Optima L-90K Ultracentrifuge, Beckman Coulter, Brea, USA). The pellet was resuspended in 0.1 M sodium phosphate buffer and DNA/RNA was extracted from the resuspended pellet following the instructions of the High Pure Viral Nucleic Acid Kit (Hoffmann-La Roche, Basel, Switzerland), without addition of carrier RNA in the lysis buffer. Three DNA/RNA samples were subjected to HTS. Next, part of all three samples were treated with DNase I (Promega, Madison, USA) in order to decrease the human or bacterial DNA in the sample for viral RNA enrichment. However, due to low amount of RNA after DNase I treatment, all three samples were mixed as one pooled sample for RNA HTS.
High-throughput sequencing - Approximately two μg of DNA/RNA and RNA samples in RNAStable tube (Biomatrica, San Diego, USA) were sent for HTS to Macrogen Inc. (Seoul, South Korea). The library of DNA/RNA or RNA samples was constructed using TruSeq Standard total RNA kit and sequenced using Illumina HiSeq 2000 with 3 G scale for each in 100 base pared-end.
Bioinformatics analysis - Low quality and adapter sequences of the raw data were trimmed using the Trimommatic tool v.036.(15) Metagenomic reads of each sample were then uploaded to Kaiju for profiling the reads in taxonomic assessment (http://kaiju.binf.ku.dk).(16) DNA reads were filtered with BWA v0.7.17(17) and SAMtools v1.9(18) against reference hg38 (Homo sapiens) obtained from GenBank to remove human DNA sequences from HTS dataset in silico. Trimmed reads were assembled into contiguous sequences (‘contigs’) with Velvet v.1.2.1(19) and SPAdes v.3.9(20) programs. The tBlastx search (https://blast.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ Blast.cgi) against the viral genome package (RefSeq Virus, NCBI, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genome/viruses/) which is implemented in the Geneious R8.1 program (Biomatters, Auckland, New Zealand) was used to identify the contig sequences which were viral origins.
RT-qPCR using PR21 kit - A part of findings by HTS analysis was confirmed by means of RT-qPCR. The RNA was extracted from original 145 samples using the Magna Pure LC Total Nucleic Acid Kit (Hoffmann-La Roche, Basel, Switzerland), then a pool of five samples were projected to the multiplex RT-qPCR using the XGen PR21 kit (Biometrix, Curitiba, Brazil) for 21 respiratory pathogens (targeting Influenza A, Influenza B, Influenza A H1N1-swl, Coronavirus NL63, Coronavirus 229E, Coronavirus OC43, Coronavirus HKU1, Parainfluenza 1, Parainfluenza 2, Parainfluenza 3, Parainfluenza 4 , Human metapneumovirus A and B, Human respiratory syncytial virus A and B, Rhinovirus, Enterovirus, Parechovirus, Human adenovirus, Bocavirus and Mycoplasma pneumoniae).
Ethics approval and consent to participate - This research project was reviewed and approved by ethics committee of the Faculty of Health Sciences (University of Brasília), approval letter No. 3.052.443.
Kaiju program is used for microbial and viral sequence profiling. For June samples a total of 87,317 (0.87%) out of 10,007,522 reads were classified as microbial sequences including virus; for July samples, 79,050 (0.96%) out of 8,215,186; for August samples 91,485 (1.11%) out of 8,271,632 and for the DNase I-treated RNA sample, 401,596 (61.26%) out of 655,558 reads were classified.
The analyses showed that nasopharyngeal secretion pooled samples of June, July and August of 2016 had similar metagenomic profiles in relation to the components of microorganisms classified found: predominance of viruses [Supplementary data (Figure)], followed by bacteria and other microorganisms, such as Archaeas. However, the higher recovery of viral sequences in DNA/RNA samples was considered as misinterpretation by Kaiju program since the later fine analyses using BLASTn found that many of the human DNA sequences present in the samples were recognised as DNA viruses due to the similarity of some genomic regions. After in silico filtration of the reads by human DNA sequences, 77.26% of reads were classified as microbial sequences for June (274,269 out of 354,975), 81.22% for July (242,730 out of 298,846) and 82.50% for August (312,605 out of 378,895). This result showed that the contamination of human DNA was problematic for virus sequence search in these samples. As the human chromosomal and microbial DNA masked the presence of RNA viruses in the total DNA/RNA samples, the amount of DNA was reduced by DNase I treatment and the samples were subjected to the HTS again as one RNA sample.
After this treatment, the microorganism profile by Kaiju program had changed, where 4% of the sample was viruses unlike the DNase I-untreated samples [Supplementary data (Figure)]. It is noted that the main microorganisms found in the RNA sample after DNase I treatment were bacteria (80%) [Supplementary data (Figure)]. The main bacterial family identified were Burkholderiaceae, Streptococcaceae, Neisseriaceae, Veillonellaceae, Pseudomonadaceae, Pasteurellaceae, Veillonellaceae and Mycoplasmataceae.
The RNA sample was the one that allowed the greater identification of RNA viruses. Therefore, the fine analyses of virus identification were performed using only the RNA sample, since most respiratory viruses possess RNA genomes. A total of 14,952 reads was classified as virus organisms. The main viruses identified using the Kaiju program were of the families Picornaviridae, Herpesviridae, Parvoviridae and Coronaviridae, with the emphasis on rhinoviruses (Table I). The same viral families were also found in the DNA/RNA sample reads after the removal of human DNA sequences in silico, however, with less frequency. Only cytomegalovirus sequences were found more in DNA/RNA samples than RNA sample (Table I), probably due to the negative effect on cytomegalovirus DNA genomes by DNase I treatment in preparation of RNA sample.
Due to low accuracy of the short-read profiling by Kaiju program, the classification up to genus level was shown in this table, except for the Enterovirus genus, which was the one with the most reads founded, allowing the virus species definition.
To identify the contig sequences (1,621 contigs assembled by Velvet and 334 by SPAdes assemblers) of viral origin, tBlastx search plugged-in Geneious was used for the known virus genome sequences recorded in the RefSeq Virus (NCBI).
The analyses identified virtually the same viral families/genera found by the Kaiju program: Picornaviridae, Herpesviridae and Parvoviridae using contigs generated by both SPAdes (Table II) and Velvet assemblers (Table III). Only the Coronaviridae family was not identified by tBlastx in Geneious (but identified by Kaiju), probably due to limited sensitivity of de novo contig assembly, although we chose the most sensitive ones, Velvet and SPAdes.(21)
It is observed in Table II (contigs assembled by SPAdes) that the number of contigs varied from 1 (Enterovirus B and C) to 12 (Rhinovirus A), with sizes of alignment between 93 and 1,239 nucleotides. The number of reads per contig also varied greatly, from 4 to 2,470 with the highest amount of reads per contig found in the Rhinovirus C species. The e-values from 5.38 x 10-148 to 1.99 x 10-11 indicates statistical significance in the alignments found using the SPAdes as assembler.
Table III shows the tBlastx results of contigs assembled by Velvet. The number of contigs varied between 1 (Enterovirus B, C and E) and 62 (Rhinovirus A) with sizes of alignment between 87 and 885 nucleotides. The number of reads per contig ranged from 3 to 962, with the highest number of reads found also for Rhinovirus C. E-values from 1.23 x 10-152 to 2.33 x 10-11 were also low, showing statistical significance of the alignment. The comparison of Tables II and III reveals that, when using Velvet as assembler, more contigs were formed, although with smaller length and fewer reads per contig. But this is important to identify more viruses in less abundance, as Human betaherpesvirus 5. Human bocavirus and Enterovirus E have been identified using Velvet, but not when using SPAdes as assembler.
The Rhinovirus sequences showed greater abundance by the presence of reads in the sample, especially Rhinovirus C, that presented highest reads number (observed in Kaiju analysis), and the highest reads number per contig (in tBlastx analysis). This shows the relevance of this one virus in these negative samples by the standard RT-qPCR.
The presence of respiratory viruses in the samples was confirmed by the PR21 multiplex RT-qPCR kit, which identifies 21 respiratory pathogens. Coronavirus 63 (CT = 30), coronavirus 43 (CT = 22-31), coronavirus HKU 1 (CT = 20-33), enterovirus (CT = 33), bocavirus (CT = 19-35) and mainly rhinovirus (CT = 21-36) were found (Figure). The RT-qPCR assay showed the presence of coronaviruses which detection was failed by the HTS Blast analyses.
The HTS has been successfully applied in several fields of virology, including virus discovery, complete virus genome sequence determination, and genomic variant analyses.(22)
Lacen-DF performs diagnosis of the respiratory virus by the standard RT-qPCR protocol with restricted targets, thus, many viruses may not be identified. The samples referred to Lacen are from patients of public and private hospitals with respiratory virus infection suspected, whether hospitalised or not. Approximately 40% of the samples forwarded are negative for the virus detection.
In this study, Human betaherpesvirus 5, Primate bocaparvovirus 1, Betacoronavirus, Enterovirus and three species of rhinovirus were found by at least two different types of analyses in samples of patients from the DF, Brazil, with flu symptoms. Human betaherpesvirus 5 (Cytomegalovirus) was identified by analyses with Kaiju and Geneious program, but not with PR21 RT-qPCR because specific primers for this pathogen were not included in the kit. DNA viruses as herpesvirus and parvovirus were also found in the sample treated with DNase I. We assume that DNase I treatment doesn’t exclude totally DNA in the sample, thus, herpesvirus and parvovirus reads were recovered. Coronavirus was identified with the Kaiju program but not by the contig analyses by tBlastx. However, its presence was confirmed by RT-qPCR of PR21 kit. Bocavirus (or Primate bocaparvovirus 1), and Enterovirus was also identified by PR21 RT-qPCR, Kaiju and Geneious programs only using Velvet, which is more sensitive method than SPAdes for contig assembly. Mycoplasma pneumoniae was found by PR21 RT-qPCR and many bacteria of the genus mycoplasma were also identified using the Kaiju program. Rhinovirus was identified using all methods used is this study.
These variations in results are explained by the differences in specificity and sensitivity in each method. For some cases, the limited sensitivity of HTS is explained by mixing some clinical samples forming one pooled sample for the cost reduction. Therefore, this sample preparation may mask the presence of viruses in low incidence or concentration. The limited capacity of de novo assembly programs is still a main problem in metagenomic analyses. Velvet and SPAdes de novo assemblers were used to build contigs in this study since these were reported as sensitive contig assembler for viral metagenomic study,(21) although there was no best de novo assembler concluded by the same authors. HTS was reported to be less sensitive than RT-qPCR for some respiratory virus detection in such reasons.(23)
Rhinovirus was the major viruses found in patients in the DF, Brazil with ILS or SARS samples which were negative by standard RT-qPCR of influenza-like surveillance (targeting Influenza A and B, Respiratory Syncytial Virus, Human Metapneumovirus, Adenovirus, Parainfluenza 1, 2 and 3). Several studies have shown the importance of rhinoviruses in acute respiratory infection in Brazil, especially in children.(24, 25, 26) A study involving 120 children less than 12 years old in São Paulo, Brazil, found that human rhinoviruses (HRV) of species A, B, and C were the most frequent agents of acute respiratory infections (ARI). Moreover, these agents are also associated with up to 70% of virus-related wheezing exacerbations. The most recently identified Rhinovirus C has been detected in association with bronchiolitis, wheezing, and asthma exacerbations requiring hospitalisation.(27)
Other study made with hospitalised patients at an academic care centre in Southern Brazil shows that HRV was usually detected in hospitalised children with respiratory infections and was often present in viral co-detections, mainly with enterovirus and respiratory syncytial virus. Comorbidities are closely associated with HRV infections, and this virus predominates during colder seasons,(28) period of which the samples used in this work were collected (winter). In investigations around the world, HRV, as well as agents causing acute respiratory infections, has its peak activity associated with the colder periods of the year.(29, 30)
In this study, the relevance of HRV in public health in Brazil was again recognised and we suggest the inclusion of HRV for influenza-like surveillance.
LCS participated in study design, accomplished the laboratory assays, contributed to data analysis and writing of the manuscript; RB analysed and interpreted the data; JMFS analysed and interpreted the data; TN participated in study design, contributed to data analysis, writing of the manuscript and coordinated the study. The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest, either of financial or nonfinancial origin, involved in the publication of this article.